Bella has just told off Billy Black, and Billy who knows what Edward and the rest of the Cullens are just shrugs his shoulders and leaves. I guess knowing that you are dating a creature that eats other people is better than not knowing even though it should change nothing in Billy's head. He drops off his fish and speeds off in his car. Bella, "stood in the hallway for a few minutes listening to the sound of their car..."
Jacob was with him as well, but he does absolutely nothing during this whole time. We know that he's got a thing for Bella, that he's kind of embarrassed about the old legends, so it's at least a little strange that he says nothing. The reader could assume that Billy and Jacob had a little conversation on the way over wherein Billy told Jacob to mind his business, but if that were the case why did Billy just take a whole bunch of guff from Bella?
There is also another problem with this section and the whole chapter: exactly what day and time is it? The dance was yesterday, so that means that today should be Sunday. Since the vampires never go out during the day, we can assume that it's late and given that it's Spring it must be around 7pm, dusk at the earliest. It's important because Bella is planning to watch Thunderball, which must take place at night during the thunderstorm. Sunday night, a school night. This is important to note but let's move on with the plot for right now.
After making sure that they are gone, she runs upstairs to try on some clothes, "now that I was removed from Jasper's and Edward's influence, I began to make up for not being terrified earlier." We can assume that Edward calms her down since she's quite neurotic and completely unsure of herself, unless she's confronting adults. Since she's completely dependent on Edward I'm unsure how his influence affected her when he had already been gone for the whole conversation. What I'm even less clear about is how Jasper is affecting her at all. It's been established that Jasper has the ability to project feelings on to other people. He can calm an entire room, why he isn't running for any kind of office doesn't make sense to me, but this is his super power. I'll buy that Bella isn't immune to it like she is to Edward's ESP, but Jasper isn't there. He wasn't in the car, and as far as we know he wasn't really paying attention to Bella at all in the house. Is the influence assumed? Should we assume the presence of Jasper's emotional manipulation every time Bella is calm and assertive? Should we picture Alice and Jasper cloaked sitting next to each other like the Fates of ancient Greece one foreseeing the future the other moving it along? Actually that last question would be a better idea for a book than this.
So it's getting to be baseball time and Bella has gone native deciding that a flannel shirt and jeans will make her outfit. She's gone grunge exactly fifteen years too late to be relevant. Her father is home and now it is time for her to bite the bullet, she's got to tell him the secret that she's been keeping for weeks for absolutely no reason. Remember Charlie Swan likes the Cullens, he's explicitly said so and even risked his relationship with his best friend because of it.
Bella runs downstairs, tells her father that Billy dropped off some fish fry for him (even though Charlie has been fishing all day), fixes dinner like a good little wife...er daughter and then drops the bomb. Charlie drops his fork. He's under the misunderstanding that Bella is seeing the older Cullen, Jasper perhaps, not Edward. Once this is cleared up he takes it well for any father listening to a story about his daughter and her first boyfriend.
I'm not exactly looking forward to that day myself but I actually hope to have Charlie's reaction...minus the dropping of the fork. All he does is clear up the information and then move on with his dinner. I've received so many pieces of conflicting advice about the subject. One school of thought, the stupid typical guy school, is to scare the boyfriend so that nothing will happen...yeah that doesn't work. I know that doesn't work because I know how teenagers work, you push really hard one way and they push back the other. The being friends with the guy isn't supposed to work because the girl will get bored or uncomfortable with the nice relationship you have and dump him for someone less friendly. Indifference won't work, because it will be false and kids can see through that kind of crap. Charlie's method of curiosity and information desire seems to be good enough. Bella still has to explain her plan for the evening.
After telling Charlie he doesn't bat an eye. Which is completely messed up. It's Sunday night, a school night, the sun is setting, it's raining, and his daughter, who is as uncoordinated as a drunk epileptic having a seizure is going to play baseball. What kind of parent is this? It makes me want to retroactively delete the preceding paragraph because of the audacity that Meyer possesses in order to get us to believe this. Edward arrives and Charlie has a short conversation with him, "So I hear that you're getting my girl to watch baseball.' Only in Washington would the fact that it was raining buckets have no bearing at all on the playing of outdoor sports."
No Bella, it's not Washington. It's Forks and whatever it is that is in the drinking water. It's not outdoor sports that is the problem, it's outdoor baseball. To me baseball is a waste of time. I've played it so I know that in driving rain you can't play baseball. No one can see the ball in order to hit it. Other sports, such as both versions of football for instance, can be played in the rain to no detriment. The fact that Charlie is a baseball fan and he ignores this basic fact of the world is all too convenient. With the coming thunderstorm he should be at least concerned about safety, but he's not, because it's essential to the plot that he lets her go. This is pure Deus Ex Machina. He doesn't even register concern when they climb into the 4x4 and Bella notes that it's raining so hard that she can't really make him out standing on the porch. If you think about it, does Charlie's existence even matter? Has it really mattered this whole time? Even when Charlie and Billy were watching the game Bella noted that they didn't talk much.
Consider also, if he didn't exist and was merely a figment of Bella's imagination what would have changed in the story thus far?
Jacob was with him as well, but he does absolutely nothing during this whole time. We know that he's got a thing for Bella, that he's kind of embarrassed about the old legends, so it's at least a little strange that he says nothing. The reader could assume that Billy and Jacob had a little conversation on the way over wherein Billy told Jacob to mind his business, but if that were the case why did Billy just take a whole bunch of guff from Bella?
There is also another problem with this section and the whole chapter: exactly what day and time is it? The dance was yesterday, so that means that today should be Sunday. Since the vampires never go out during the day, we can assume that it's late and given that it's Spring it must be around 7pm, dusk at the earliest. It's important because Bella is planning to watch Thunderball, which must take place at night during the thunderstorm. Sunday night, a school night. This is important to note but let's move on with the plot for right now.
After making sure that they are gone, she runs upstairs to try on some clothes, "now that I was removed from Jasper's and Edward's influence, I began to make up for not being terrified earlier." We can assume that Edward calms her down since she's quite neurotic and completely unsure of herself, unless she's confronting adults. Since she's completely dependent on Edward I'm unsure how his influence affected her when he had already been gone for the whole conversation. What I'm even less clear about is how Jasper is affecting her at all. It's been established that Jasper has the ability to project feelings on to other people. He can calm an entire room, why he isn't running for any kind of office doesn't make sense to me, but this is his super power. I'll buy that Bella isn't immune to it like she is to Edward's ESP, but Jasper isn't there. He wasn't in the car, and as far as we know he wasn't really paying attention to Bella at all in the house. Is the influence assumed? Should we assume the presence of Jasper's emotional manipulation every time Bella is calm and assertive? Should we picture Alice and Jasper cloaked sitting next to each other like the Fates of ancient Greece one foreseeing the future the other moving it along? Actually that last question would be a better idea for a book than this.
So it's getting to be baseball time and Bella has gone native deciding that a flannel shirt and jeans will make her outfit. She's gone grunge exactly fifteen years too late to be relevant. Her father is home and now it is time for her to bite the bullet, she's got to tell him the secret that she's been keeping for weeks for absolutely no reason. Remember Charlie Swan likes the Cullens, he's explicitly said so and even risked his relationship with his best friend because of it.
Bella runs downstairs, tells her father that Billy dropped off some fish fry for him (even though Charlie has been fishing all day), fixes dinner like a good little wife...er daughter and then drops the bomb. Charlie drops his fork. He's under the misunderstanding that Bella is seeing the older Cullen, Jasper perhaps, not Edward. Once this is cleared up he takes it well for any father listening to a story about his daughter and her first boyfriend.
I'm not exactly looking forward to that day myself but I actually hope to have Charlie's reaction...minus the dropping of the fork. All he does is clear up the information and then move on with his dinner. I've received so many pieces of conflicting advice about the subject. One school of thought, the stupid typical guy school, is to scare the boyfriend so that nothing will happen...yeah that doesn't work. I know that doesn't work because I know how teenagers work, you push really hard one way and they push back the other. The being friends with the guy isn't supposed to work because the girl will get bored or uncomfortable with the nice relationship you have and dump him for someone less friendly. Indifference won't work, because it will be false and kids can see through that kind of crap. Charlie's method of curiosity and information desire seems to be good enough. Bella still has to explain her plan for the evening.
After telling Charlie he doesn't bat an eye. Which is completely messed up. It's Sunday night, a school night, the sun is setting, it's raining, and his daughter, who is as uncoordinated as a drunk epileptic having a seizure is going to play baseball. What kind of parent is this? It makes me want to retroactively delete the preceding paragraph because of the audacity that Meyer possesses in order to get us to believe this. Edward arrives and Charlie has a short conversation with him, "So I hear that you're getting my girl to watch baseball.' Only in Washington would the fact that it was raining buckets have no bearing at all on the playing of outdoor sports."
No Bella, it's not Washington. It's Forks and whatever it is that is in the drinking water. It's not outdoor sports that is the problem, it's outdoor baseball. To me baseball is a waste of time. I've played it so I know that in driving rain you can't play baseball. No one can see the ball in order to hit it. Other sports, such as both versions of football for instance, can be played in the rain to no detriment. The fact that Charlie is a baseball fan and he ignores this basic fact of the world is all too convenient. With the coming thunderstorm he should be at least concerned about safety, but he's not, because it's essential to the plot that he lets her go. This is pure Deus Ex Machina. He doesn't even register concern when they climb into the 4x4 and Bella notes that it's raining so hard that she can't really make him out standing on the porch. If you think about it, does Charlie's existence even matter? Has it really mattered this whole time? Even when Charlie and Billy were watching the game Bella noted that they didn't talk much.
Consider also, if he didn't exist and was merely a figment of Bella's imagination what would have changed in the story thus far?
No comments:
Post a Comment